• 0 Posts
  • 137 Comments
Joined 3 days ago
cake
Cake day: September 3rd, 2025

help-circle
  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    7 hours ago

    You’re not talking about what esteem we hold the government’s in, or they’re assorted ills. We are talking about the structure of government, being representative, or being autocratic. You can say but those representative governments were mean! No shit? That is not what is an issue here. You could discount any event from history with the logic you are trying to use here.



  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    8 hours ago

    When the Constitution was written if you had land you could vote, it did not matter if it was a million Acres or a half an acre. You each got one vote. Also there really were very few manufacturing workers, like 90% was in agriculture.

    Now you want to talk about the failings of the western governments go ahead, I am the first to bring those up. But it would be a whole lot worse with a one-party state. A lot worse. We have different groups of people and deep divisions within our groups and the worst people in the country in charge. At least some of these other large autocracies have a smart person in charge evil and ruthless though they may be. We have evil ruthless and utterly malicious. Nihilistic. We are not starting with Octavian caesar, but with caracalla.

    Now if you think Western governments are worse towards their citizens than Eastern ones I would straight up disagree. Due to honest elections we have extracted more from lawmakers than an autocrat who’s only fear would be a bloody Revolution.






  • Part of the difference now is that before it was the National Security type people that had the information, no the politicians themselves will be able to access it, as well as numerous outside groups able to hack the system. So it is a world of difference even if the internet is compromised on a basic level. Especially now with these computer programs able to sort and make assumptions however unfounded about people.




  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 hours ago

    Oh my God this is the dumbest logic that the rich sponsor to derail any example to meet from the great generation. Because everything was not perfect nothing from that era counts.

    You could not use a single example from history with that logic. You could discredit anything anyone has done ever if there was injustice.

    Give me one example, one historical example that could be used while not being discounted because their society was not perfect?

    And regardless a minimum wage job paid for life, the factory job paid for a downright prosperous life, antitrust laws were enforced, we paid a reasonable amount of money for goods, and so forth.


  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 hours ago

    The Soviet Union got ganged up on by all the capitalist countries because everyone was scared shitless of socialism, all the super rich made sure they were attacked in any way possible, at one point they were fighting on 17 different fronts with the largest standing army the world has ever seen.

    All of those attacks I believe led to their army gaming an outsized power that allowed them to seize control with a strong man and turning the government against what it should have been.

    Stalin was a monster by all accounts. Maybe if Lennon or Trotsky were leading things it could have been different. Trotsky who got ice picked in the head by an assassin in Mexico City at a speech he was giving, by stalin’s agent.

    As to the Democratic conventions, it was all fixed. There was some degree of voting at the beginning right after the revolution, the Bolsheviks got elected and then they got voted out the next Congress or whatever they called it and they kept power. Very few if any of their elections were honest to my knowledge.



  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 hours ago

    What does that have to do with the West having their representative governments replaced with autocracies?

    In case you are unaware by the way, plenty of people go without here. We have been getting squeezed for 50 years and we are now at the point where a full-time job does not pay for life for a larger number of people.

    And I bet if you need to see a doctor you would not be forced to pay 10 times what everybody else in the world pays and a hundred times for a drug.

    The victims of the United States government includes United States citizens.

    The war on poverty of Linden B Johnson turned into a war against those in poverty. Their own undesirables. A rank that will grow and grow in numbers in time.

    To reiterate, I did not originally say anything wrong, and to refer to Eastern governments principally refers to the near East and Middle East. But it also does apply to China.


  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    9 hours ago

    It had a lot to do with tens of millions of union members and their Associates standing up and fighting together. Without that the United States would still be sending kids down in Coal Mines, the old thrown out in the street to die, etc.

    Obviously we have been going back to that place for a long time, half a century, that is the problem.


  • hector@lemmy.todaytomemes@hexbear.netHow much longer...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 hours ago

    I thought y’all were the PC brigade. But as I explained multiple times, eastern governments historically is in reference to the near East as well as North Africa and indeed Russia.

    And I’m not bashing communists but autocratic government ruled by a single power.

    The classic example Is Egypt where they decreed their leader a god. But that was pretty standard practice for a lot of the area in the ancient Days in the East. While Rome had elections and when the Empire started and they declared themselves a god it was for the benefit of their Eastern provinces and they were roundly mocked for it at home.

    Regardledd a one party kakistocracy, rule of the worst, will be a nightmare here in the United States. Given the Deep divisions and diversity of peoples here. And all the money and asseys to steal.

    It will also bring a return to the 1980s style meddling in other governments. Supporting military coups and death squads in Latin America and elsewhere.

    I could also point out that China is not actually communist. They are playing to the greed of Western capitalists to Garner our technology and get their factories built for them. Long term it’s smart, it sucks for all of their workers though, and all of the pollution that is not well regulated.