• tal@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    edit-2
    2 days ago

    Specific to the Threadiverse, not the Fediverse, I’d like to have syntax to refer to posts and comments in a home-instance-agnostic way (so I can link to a post or comment in such a way that someone following the link stays on their own home instance), and I’d like to make it easier to link to groups in a home-instance-agnostic-way (!community@instance isn’t obvious to new users not familiar with the Threadiverse).

    IIRC, PieFed rewrites links to other Threadiverse instances to point to the home instance. That has its own problems, since sometimes (e.g. when doing technical troubleshooting), one wants to specifically link to a post on a particular instance.

    I think that maybe the best fix would be on the client side, at post time, to look for links to other Threadiverse instances and offer to convert them at post time to home-instance-agnostic links.

    On a related note, I think that the separation between usernames and display names creates problems in referring to users. As things stand, referencing a user must be done with @user@instance syntax. However, a user can have entirely-separate display name. One prominent example that probably many might be familiar with is @kolanaki@pawb.social:

    username: Kolanaki@pawb.social

    display name: 🇰 🌀 🇱 🇦 🇳 🇦 🇰 🇮@pawb.social

    He chose a display name that looks similar to his username, just with a bit of Unicode styling…but there’s no technically-enforced requirement that a user actually do so. A user can make anything they want show up there.

    The problem is that this makes it harder to learn or remember usernames to do @user@instance references, and given that I think that a lot of Threadiverse users aren’t familiar with this display name functionality and will naturally think that a display name is a username, it creates potential for impersonation or similar problems. Unicode has historically been vulnerable to similar-characters attacks when used for identifiers.

    I’d just drop the display name functionality, or if it must be kept, permit for a short display name that is appended to the username in a clearly-distinct-from-the-username way.

    EDIT: For some examples that might be more-confusing (i.e. they don’t use Unicode or spaces and look to someone not familiar with the feature like they could be a username in the vanilla Lemmy Web UI), looking in this post, as of this writing one has:

    username: bhamlin@lemmy.world
    display name: Billegh@lemmy.world

    username: snooggums@piefed.world
    display name: [deleted]@piefed.world (a user probably wouldn’t think that this is a username, but might think that the account was deleted)

    username: mesamunefire@piefed.social
    display name: mesa@piefed.social

    It’s not obvious to a user that it’s a display name present. Now say someone does that, but with the aim of impersonating someone else.