Note that while I get the benefit, one historic mechanism for trolling on Usenet relied on the fact that many clients would respond to both Usenet groups if a post was cross-posted.
This meant that one could post troll bait cross-posted to two groups that had userbases that didn’t agree with each other, and watch as a flamewar ensued. E.g. “I’m thinking about getting a Mac or a Windows PC and am not sure which is better. I heard from my friend that Macs kind of suck. Can you help explain?” to comp.sys.mac.advocacy and comp.sys.ms-windows.advocacy or something.
Reddit avoided this by not having responses visible to users visible to both groups. It just linked to cross-posts.
PieFed’s merging of crossposts to users of both groups helps address federation-induced fragmentation on the Threadiverse (multiple “linux” communities effectively act as one ad-hoc community for the life of a given crosspost). But it also lets a malicious crossposter force users of arbitrary groups into one discussion, and I can say that that definitely led to problems in the past.
PieFed does this already. For instance, you can see that this article was posted 29 times and had a total of 159 comments:
And then when viewing the post, the comments are organized below into each community:
Note: The totals given for each community don’t seem to line up with the overall total. It might be a bug caused by deleted comments.
Note that while I get the benefit, one historic mechanism for trolling on Usenet relied on the fact that many clients would respond to both Usenet groups if a post was cross-posted.
This meant that one could post troll bait cross-posted to two groups that had userbases that didn’t agree with each other, and watch as a flamewar ensued. E.g. “I’m thinking about getting a Mac or a Windows PC and am not sure which is better. I heard from my friend that Macs kind of suck. Can you help explain?” to comp.sys.mac.advocacy and comp.sys.ms-windows.advocacy or something.
Reddit avoided this by not having responses visible to users visible to both groups. It just linked to cross-posts.
PieFed’s merging of crossposts to users of both groups helps address federation-induced fragmentation on the Threadiverse (multiple “linux” communities effectively act as one ad-hoc community for the life of a given crosspost). But it also lets a malicious crossposter force users of arbitrary groups into one discussion, and I can say that that definitely led to problems in the past.
Was there moderation and/or defederation on Usenet?
Piefed/Pylova comments consolidation has been in place for a long time now, there hasn’t been any report of increased flamewars due tot his.
There was limited moderation in some groups, which I think relied on cancel messages. But in general, no.
It would be nice if other platforms had the same kinda deal.
Its very hard to do in practice so I kinda get it.
I noticed that the communities and accounts I have blocked still count towards the displayed combined total.