• 1 Post
  • 22 Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: July 10th, 2024

help-circle
  • Mostly agree with these. And I’m pretty happy with the bracket model so far. It does however require everyone at the table to be using the intent in good faith, and not strictly looking at the letter of the law.

    I’m blown away that Mana Drain didn’t make the list. I feel guilty playing it at all, and have even taken decks apart that I felt became too powerful because of it. It’s one of those cards that when I see it used, I’m like “Oh, I didn’t realize we were playing at that power level”.

    I’m also surprised to see Gamble & Deflecting Swat on the list. I feel like they looked at the list and said “We’ve got to also include some red cards too. But nothing in red is all that great. Well, shit. What does red have that’s cheap to cast?”


  • We never really back up and say ‘did you REALLY get that part, because you’re going to NEED it for the next 14 years?’. I can remember I was sick for multiple weeks when we were learning division. I came back, and we were already onto the next topic, and it was just assumed I knew it. Now, I was super-lucky, in that I understood multiplication well enough to puzzle it out. Not every student cares, especially when they are like 8 years old. Just want to learn it enough to pass and be done with Math. ‘What do you mean I have more Math next year too???’

    As soon as you miss a single step in the mathematics education train, well, you’re going to be hating math for the rest of your schooling. It’s a series of incremental building blocks, but we never double check that each student really has each piece.






  • No.

    But to be clear, somewhere over the last 20 years it seems I’ve also fallen out of the middle class? I bought a new car fresh out of college, and then again about 10 years later. But I look at the price of new cars today, and they’re simply not a purchase I can afford. So, it looks like I’m not going to be buying any new cars anymore, Tesla or otherwise. That feels weird.


  • I was blown away when my die-hard Republican boomer dad said he thinks climate change is real. There’s a pond behind our house, and he can remember how big it used to get in the rainy season and how small it used to get in the dry season. Now, during the rainy season it comes up to the backdoor, and during the dry season it’s not there at all. If he can still trust his own eyes over what the TV tells him to think, maybe there’s still some hope for the world.


  • ptc075@lemmy.ziptoSpoilers[TDM] Ringing Strike Mastery
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 month ago

    Just played Pauper a few weeks ago with some friends, and pulled out Paralyze as something old school & unique to throw at the group. At the time, I was thinking, hey, here’s a mechanic that I don’t think has ever been revisited. Not sure if I like it more in blue or in black, but the power creep bothers me. And yes, I know, this is small potatoes compared to some of the other shenanigans going on.







  • This reminds me of the first time I ever saw Magic. I was hosting a very small convention at Georgia Tech (Techwood Con, Woo!), and on the last day, two different dudes showed asking if anyone had any Magic cards for sale. Only a few of us even knew what they were talking about. Turns out they were specifically hoping to buy any of what we now call the power 9. And they of course knew each other, since they were both traveling all over Georgia hoping to find & buy these specific cards.

    Since the day was a bust for them, they grabbed a table and started playing each other. Keep in mind, this was Alpha/Beta timeframe, the rules were still very loose, we were years away from a restricted list. They each had a 40 card deck with pretty much nothing but Mox’s for mana. Each one of them would draw, win the game on their opening turn, and then start a new game where the other guy would go first and also win on his opening turn. They went back and forth like this until one of them failed to win on their opening draw.

    That being my very first introduction to Magic, I totally understand and appreciate why we have rules in place to slow the game down. But there was no denying that these two dudes were having fun. So, no shade at folks who like to play at that power level, it’s just not the reason I choose to shuffle up & play. I’m kinda glad we have so many different variations of Magic available, so that everyone can find the one that’s right for them.



  • ptc075@lemmy.ziptoMTGIntroducing Commander Brackets Beta
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    Honestly, this starts out strong. Have a conversation - do you have mass land denial, extra turns, or fast/2 card infinite combos? But then we get to the game changers section, and it feels like they kinda ran out of steam and just said “we don’t like these cards”. I don’t specifically disagree with the list, but there’s too many similar cards that aren’t listed, because - well, where do you draw the line? It would make more sense to focus on function (Fast mana, Tutors, etc.), and THEN provide examples for guidance. And they do sort-of do this at the bottom of the article, but it gets muddy fast. Which is why everyone is looking at the list of “game changer” cards instead. And already mapping out the next best in slot replacements.

    Also, ‘Sol Ring should be on this list, but it isn’t, because dad said so’ is not the wining argument they think it is.





  • Have Red cards in general come down in price since the ban? There’s a view in my group that Red was already the weakest of the 5 colors. And with Dockside gone, now Red is even further disadvantaged. So, we’re expecting to see even fewer Red decks, which ought to mean that the price of other good Red staples would slide.

    Now, this is working out great for me - we sometimes play a Commander variant we call Crapmander, where no single card can be worth more than $5. I was just able to build a Crapmander mono Red deck that I’m quite excited about. From my little world, it sure seems like there’s some REALLY undervalued red cards below the $5 point. Just curious if that’s just a ‘me’ thing, or if the whole community sees it too.